• About us
    Who We AreStaff DirectoryBoard of DirectorsHall of FameMember AwardsStrategic Plan / Annual ReportsCommittees/CommunitiesCode of EthicsEducational FoundationEquity, Diversity & Inclusion
  • Advocacy
    IP IncentivesIPIC SubmissionsIPIC Intervention Policy
  • What is IP?
     IP BasicsOwn it. CampaignWhy Use a ProfessionalHow to Become an AgentIndigenous Traditional Knowledge
  • Education
    Certification ProgramsCourses & EventsMentorship Program
  • Resources
    COVID-19 UpdatesNewsCIPRFind an IP ProfessionalIPIC Job Bank2019 Compensation StudyMedia KitIP Assist
  • Membership
    Your profession. Our purpose.Join NowMember BenefitsMember CategoriesMember Referral ProgramInsurance Program: IP Agent Insurance
  • 0
  • FR
Kimberley Baillie
MBM Intellectual Property Law
Topics
Share

A Reflection on Nice Classification in 2022 and The Coming-Into Force of the 12th EditionA Reflection on Nice Classification in 2022 and The Coming-Into Force of the 12th Edition

Published on December 9, 2022

At the 32nd Session of the Nice Committee of Experts it was confirmed that the 12th Edition of the Nice Classification will come into force this January 1, 2023.

This new Edition reflects changes to the Nice Classification Headings, a few transfers with respect to goods, but does not contain any transfers with respect to services. Most notably “dispensers” have been transferred and will now be classified according to material composition.

The 12th Edition is also the first new edition since Nice became a requirement for filing applications in Canada and must be used after January 1, 2023.

While the Canadian Intellectual Property Office should continue to process applications filed under the 11th Edition of Nice Classification under that particular edition, it will be interesting to see how the Office handles the coming-into-force of this new edition.

As we near the end of 2022, a review below of a few notable topics that generated significant discussion with the Committee of Experts, as well as in the global IP community:

  1. Cannabis

The debate continues for the Nice Classification of cannabis products. (See: UnsrIPted 2019 Article: Canada’s Trademark Applications for Marijuana Products and Services Cause an International Stir at the Committee of Experts).

This year Denmark spearheaded the discussion with their belief that all cannabis products should be placed in Class 5 and encourages the Committee to agree on this approach. The support for this position stemmed from English dictionary definitions translated into Danish to indicate that cannabis is only a drug and, therefore, anything to do with cannabis should be placed in Class 5. Denmark voiced further concerns that use of the term “recreational” to distinguish from medical use could mean that any form of any other drug could also be referenced in this manner.

Denmark encourages companies that have cannabis as a feature of the product to avoid using reference to the “cannabis” if they do not want their products placed in Class 5. For example, “skin lotion containing cannabis” would be placed in Class 3 in Canada, but as this contains reference to cannabis, this would be placed in Class 5 in Denmark. The delegate stated that if the product is simply “skin lotion,” reference to “containing cannabis” is unnecessary as this is an ingredient in the product.

Delegates from France and the UK added that adding cannabis products to the Nice Alphabetical list sends a message to users that these prohibited goods may be acceptable in applications.  Currently, the French Intellectual Property Office refuses applications that contains reference to cannabis unless they are for medical use.

The German delegate stated that it is difficult to include reference to these products in the Nice Alphabetical List as the legality of cannabis differs in many member states. Then stated that perhaps the distribution of these products should influence classification. The delegate gave the example that if the goods are only sold in pharmacies and drug stores then they should be in Class 5. However, Germany did not comment on recreational cannabis. 

The USPTO position is well known and their classification philosophy is closely tied to the legality issue they face in the United States.

Israel, Australia and Switzerland continues to support the classification methodology of Canada by main purpose of the product. Surprisingly, Norway volunteered that they are of the opinion that they would also like to follow this approach.

Most delegates agree that if the US legalizes cannabis, this would change the landscape for many IPOs and it will be beneficial to determine an appropriate global approach to the classification of these goods. 

  1. Non-fungible Tokens (NFTs)

The US took the lead in the presenting the proposal for non-fungible tokens (NFTs) indicating that this is a new term rapidly evolving in the marketplace. NFTs are data stored on a blockchain that represent digital items and authenticate their ownership. The proposal for “downloadable digital music files authenticated by non-fungible tokens [NFTs]” was to provide guidance regarding this new technology and clarify that the classification of NFTs is based on the item represented by the NFT.

It was resolved that the broader term “downloadable digital files authenticated by non-fungible tokens [NFTs]” would be added to the Nice Alphabetical List in Class 9.

As all “downloadable digital files” are placed in Class 9, despite how they are “authenticated,” this wording seemed to be a reasonable way to include reference to NFTs in the Nice Alphabetical List. 

  1. War in Ukraine

Russia’s actions in the Ukraine influenced the tone of the session as United Nations delegates joined the Committee to make statements. The delegate from Ukraine stressed the importance of the Committee to aid the world in the effort to resume business as usual post-pandemic.  However, business as usual is not possible for Ukraine, as most government employees are hiding throughout the country. The delegate formally asked WIPO to condemn Russian actions against Ukraine.

A number of UN delegates also took the floor to condemn Russian actions. The US UN delegate indicated that WIPO should not stand by as one member state not only seriously affects IP rights globally, but also causes catastrophic loss of life in another member state. The UK UN delegate indicated that as WIPO, as a UN body, is mandated to protect the body of IP rights holders and Russian actions are affecting the rights holders in Ukraine. The Canadian UN delegate indicated that Russia shattered peace and security in Europe and this was an attack on international laws including the UN charter and Russia must be held to account. Opinions of other UN delegates present and those of the Committee were also in agreement.

However, the Russian UN delegate suggested that countries were taking the opportunity to politicize the nature of the Committee of Experts and did not affect the substance of the current meeting nor the points outlined on the agenda.

As a number of global brands pulled out of Russia and the war in Ukraine continues, as cannabis and NFTs are still trending up, we are reminded how brands, trends and world events can alter the economic status of a nation and influence the world of intellectual property.

 

 

Related Articles

May 12, 2023

Tips and Tricks for Effective Virtual Advocacy

Ryan Wong
As a junior IP litigator, I find myself having a lot of questions about what it means to be an effective advocate in these “modern” times. I am among the first cohort of students to cut my teeth as a 2L summer and articling student wholly during the COVID-19 pandemic. As a result, my legal experience has been one of constant adjustments. I’ve witnessed our profession’s incredible ability to adapt and react to unprecedented times.
TopicsEmerging Leaders Committee
May 5, 2023

Practice Tips for Emerging IP Practitioners Looking to Work In-House

Anastassia Trifonova
Today's emerging IP practitioners have a wide range of career options. While IP work was traditionally handled exclusively by law firms, more and more businesses are now seeking IP specialists to complement their in-house legal teams. As organizations strive to optimize their internal legal resources, IP lawyers and agents alike can bring valuable expertise to the table. This article aims to provides helpful tips for IP professionals who are looking to succeed in-house.
TopicsEmerging Leaders Committee
April 24, 2023

Join IPIC & its Educational Foundation in recognizing World IP Day 2023 on April 26th

Kevin Shipley, Nicole Mantini
The theme of this year’s World IP Day is an important reminder that many segments of Canadian society do not have equal access to the necessary resources and tools to thrive in our profession. IPIC has been focused on raising awareness and working to make meaningful, positive change in respect of these issues. Since 2019, IPIC's Educational Foundation’s [Patent & Trademark Institute Educational Foundation (PTIEF)] mandate has been to encourage education and scholarship in the IP field with a focus on promoting diversity and inclusion among IP professionals and removing barriers to access for members of under-represented groups interested in pursuing educational opportunities in the IP field.
TopicsFoundation Committee EDI Educational Foundation

MISSION

Our mission is to enhance our members’ expertise as trusted intellectual property advisors, and to shape a policy and business environment that encourages the development, use, and value of intellectual property.


VISION

Our vision is for IPIC to be the leading authority on intellectual property in Canada, and the voice of intellectual property professionals.

LATEST TWEETS

Twitter feed is currently not available

CONTACT US

360 Albert Street, Suite 550
Ottawa, ON K1R 7X7

T 613-234-0516
E admin@ipic.ca

LAND ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

The IPIC office is located in Ottawa, on the traditional, unceded territories of the Algonquin Anishinaabeg people.

©2021 Intellectual Property Institute of Canada, Ottawa, ON
Designed by Ottawa Web Design driven by Member Management Software